Why It's Impossible to Tune a Piano
Channel:minutephysics · Length:4:19 · Published:2015-09-17 · Views:4144627
Summary
A minutephysics video explaining why a piano cannot be perfectly tuned, comparing equal temperament with just intonation and the math of harmonics.
Why HN recommends it
Commenters link it as a quick, clear explanation of why twelve notes only approximate simple ratios.
minutephysics had a nice video about the mathematics that go behind piano tuning too. — HN, 2019
Recreational & visual math · Everyday physics & science demos · Music theory, synthesis & production
Subtitles (excerpt)
Aah, the sound of shaking animal intestines.. I mean, strings which are traditionally made out of cat gut but regardless of what it's made out of when a string vibrates it does so with the ends fixed to the instrument. This means that it can only vibrate in certain waves, sin waves. Like a jump rope with one bump or two bumps or three or four or some combination of these bumps. The more bumps the higher the pitch and the faster the string has to vibrate. In fact, the frequency of a strings vibration is exactly equal to the number of bumps times the strings fundamental frequency that is, the frequency of vibrations for a single bump. And since most melodious instruments use either strings or air vibrating pipes which has the same sinusoidal behavior it won't surprise you to hear that musicians have different names for the different ratios between these pitches. In the traditional Western scale, 1 to 2 bumps is called an octave; 2 to 3 is a perfect fifth; 3 to 4 is a perfect fourth, then a major third, minor third some other things that aren't on the scale and from 8 to 9 bumps is a major second or whole step. If you play a few of these notes together you get the nice sound of perfect harmony. Hence the name for this band of
On Hacker News
I can help with a couple of these. 12 notes is a kludge, because powers of 2^(1/12) well approximate simple ratios. These simple ratios (such as 3:2) sound good. I like this video for explanation: [VIDEO] Also, the reason that the letters are in the wrong order is that we're playing the wrong scale. The monks who invented the scale usually sang in A-minor (so we use the first letter for that scal… — voting749227383, 2021-07
minutephysics had a nice video about the mathematics that go behind piano tuning too. "Why It's Impossible to Tune a Piano" [VIDEO] — ramanan, 2019-03
A related video on the numbers behind piano music, on why it is mathematically impossible to perfectly tune a piano : [VIDEO] — ramanan, 2015-11
To +1 the "no objective foundation": browse music theory research a bit! There's a ton of caveats and poor-sounding fits and whatnot for literally every approach, and there's endless discussion of it. E.g. have a MinutePhysics take on how the common 12 note western scale falls apart: [VIDEO] And that's before even getting into completely alternate approaches, or how strongly harmonics affect perc… — Groxx, 2026-06
Related videos
- How Do Bikes Stay Up? · minutephysics · 3:57
- Vectors | Chapter 1, Essence of linear algebra · 3Blue1Brown · 9:51
- AT&T Archives: Similiarities of Wave Behavior (Bonus Edition) · AT&T Tech Channel · 28:02
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- But what is a neural network? | Deep learning chapter 1 · 3Blue1Brown · 18:40
- Heat Pumps: the Future of Home Heating · Technology Connections · 35:15
- The Beauty of Bézier Curves · Freya Holmér · 24:25
- The Continuity of Splines · Freya Holmér · 1:13:50
- Jim Simons (full length interview) - Numberphile · Numberphile2 · 1:00:43
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- But how does bitcoin actually work? · 3Blue1Brown · 25:15
- Conway's Game Of Life in APL · Dyalog · 7:47
- The essence of calculus · 3Blue1Brown · 17:04
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius · Tantacrul · 21:35
- The man with 1,000 Klein Bottles UNDER his house - Numberphile · Numberphile · 6:49