Blockchains Are a Bad Idea (James Mickens)

Channel:HBS Digital Initiative · Length:14:34 · Published:2018-06-04 · Views:68176

Watch on YouTube

Summary

James Mickens of Harvard gives a funny lecture at HBS's Future Assembly arguing that blockchains are a very bad idea. He covers their trust, legal and practical shortcomings for real-world problems.

Why HN recommends it

A staple HN recommendation in crypto and Web3 threads as an entertaining, compelling case against blockchain.

James Mickens' "Blockchains are a bad idea" talk [1] is a great explanation that discusses exactly that. — HN, 2021

Cryptography · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] [Music] okay my talk is called why blockchains are a bad idea I know that most of you in this audience I've ugh been told throughout your whole life blockchains are the solutions to all your problems you got supply chain management data that you want to store make it highly available put it on the blockchain you got medical records that you want to make available to patients to doctors put it on the blockchain okay there's more let's say you've got land deed documents who owns certain pieces of property what do we do we don't oh that's right we do put it on the blockchain right interstate Medical Licensing how do we make these licenses available to different states when doctors move put it on the blockchain okay it's a blockchain Christmas for everyone okay or Kwanzaa or Hanukkah because I respect all face okay but let's slow down a little bit okay let's ask ourselves the question what properties do block chains provide and then what properties do applications actually need I'm gonna argue that there's a mismatch between these things so at a very high level what is a blockchain it's three things it's distributed storage that's where we're gonna store the data that's in the blockchain it's smart contracts that's what's

On Hacker News

James Mickens' "Blockchains are a bad idea" talk [1] is a great explanation that discusses exactly that. [1]: [VIDEO] — asciimike, 2021-09
James Mickens gave an entertaining presentation about why blockchain is poorly suited for most application use cases: [VIDEO] — thesuperbigfrog, 2023-08
Web3 requires retrofitting the web to use blockchain technologies to do what the web can mostly do already. In "Blockchains Are a Bad Idea", James Mickens gives several arguments against blockchain-based systems like Bitcoin: See his presentation here: [VIDEO] 1. People have out-of-band trust relationships in real life which reduce the likelihood of malice. Bitcoin-style anonymous identities unde… — thesuperbigfrog, 2021-11
Web3 requires retrofitting the web to use blockchain technologies to do what the web can mostly do already. In "Blockchains Are a Bad Idea", James Mickens gives several arguments against blockchain-based systems like Bitcoin: See his presentation here: [VIDEO] 1. People have out-of-band trust relationships in real life which reduce the likelihood of malice. Bitcoin-style anonymous identities unde… — thesuperbigfrog, 2021-11
Exactly. Making money on blockchain requires retrofitting the web to use blockchain to do what the web can mostly do already. In "Blockchains Are a Bad Idea", James Mickens gives several arguments against blockchain-based systems like Bitcoin: See his presentation here: [VIDEO] 1. People have out-of-band trust relationships in real life which reduce the likelihood of malice. Bitcoin-style anonymo… — thesuperbigfrog, 2021-10

Related videos