Andreessen's Corollary: Ethical Dilemmas in Software Engineering - Bryan Cantrill | Craft 2019

Channel:CraftHub Events · Length:46:24 · Published:2019-05-17 · Views:26829

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Bryan Cantrill's Craft 2019 talk on the ethical dilemmas software engineers face as software eats the world. He explores cases where engineering thinking conflicts with the law or personal morals, including Facebook's news feed experiments.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a good talk on ethics in software engineering, and Cantrill himself cites it as capturing his views.

Bryan Cantrill (DTrace etc) has a good talk on ethics in software engineering[0]. — HN, 2021

Software practice, open source & careers · Philosophy & ethics · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

Alrighty. Excellent. Um, good afternoon everybody. It's great to be at at Craftcom. Uh, this is a conference that has given me FOMO for many years. Fear of missing out. Um, it's great to actually be here. And one of the things they asked us to do as we were loading our presentations is to offer tags on the presentations. And I realized that I I couldn't quite bring myself to do it, but I should have tagged history on my talk because honestly all my talks begin with a bit of history. Uh, and I'm I'm talking today about ethical dilemmas in software engineering. And so I'm going to turn the way back dial um to 1997. Um, I'm not going to ask how many of you are alive in 1997 because I know that I think that most of you are, but I know that is changing. So I'd know not to ask that question even. But if we look at at the the the code of ethics from the ACM circa 1997 this is these were published in the communications of the ACM um and you know they they start off with these kind of timeless ideas. So certainly um it is as true now much or even more true that computers have a central and growing role in commerce industry industry government medicine education entertainment social affairs and ordinary life.

On Hacker News

Bryan Cantrill (DTrace etc) has a good talk on ethics in software engineering[0]. Skip to 12:29 where he recalls Facebook in 2011 experimenting with users news feeds. [0] [VIDEO] — earleybird, 2021-12
Bryan Cantrill has a talk on YT on ethics in software [1]. And as I remember it the take away is that the way we think about problems isn't very conducive to obeying the law, or being good to people in general. And I've got to say the amount of people I see thinking of regulations, social norms or morals as « cruft » is pretty alarming. [1] [VIDEO] — Bayart, 2020-12
This year's Cantrill talks include one on Ethical Dilemmas [0] and another on the "Moore's Law" paper [1]. Highly recommend both. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — bitofhope, 2019-12
It was also born by the guy - Zuck and arguably in a similar spirit - who initially created a hot or not webpage to rank female college classmates by "fuckability". No clue how any of this would come as a surprise if you know his history. Brian Cantrill talks about how social media was born crocked [1] while referring to the eerily similar friendster backstory. [1] [VIDEO] — Voultapher, 2025-03
I am glad to see that many people are being correcting you, but just to put a sharp point on it: I am using that metaphor to condemn Ellison, not to condone or accept him. Unfortunately, since that talk in 2011, what was an aberration (albeit a broadly unspoken one) has since -- tragically -- become the norm. I refuse to accept this, however: I will continue to speak my truth about the moral deca… — bcantrill, 2025-02

Related videos