Apple's soldered-in SSDs are engineered in the worst way possible

Channel:Louis Rossmann · Length:33:32 · Published:2023-08-04 · Views:589863

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Louis Rossmann, an independent repair technician, explains why he thinks Apple's soldered-in SSDs are a poor design. He covers failure modes and repair difficulty on MacBook logic boards.

Why HN recommends it

HN mostly cites it in critiques of Apple's hardware choices and base-model storage and memory, as an example of a design flaw.

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Hardware (other)

Subtitles (excerpt)

hey everybody how's it going hope you're having a lovely day today I'm going to rant on the fact that soldering ssds are a Cancer upon Computing and why I think it is a bad idea that this was ever implemented in a smartphone you really need this thing to be ultra thin it fits in your pocket I understand the idea of soldering on the main storage particularly since a smartphone on average is just not a device where you're going to be expecting to have 50 or 70 terabytes of ride Cycles like you would to I don't know a computer that's designed to be used for a high-end video editing in graphics and video production and everything else if you have a computer that isn't marketed to people as something that is going to be used in this way you should expect that it's going to get a lot of right Cycles to it in the way that a smartphone won't which means that it may die further since the computer costs a lot more than a smartphone having to replace the entire thing because the SSD died is far more offensive in a three thousand or four thousand dollar computer than it is on a five or six hundred dollar smartphone a SSD the solid state drive the nand is aware of part it's not the same as Ram or a CPU again you can expect the CPU to keep

On Hacker News

Not if you're powerusing it like in the Article and relying heavily on Swap. Also there are countless reports of bricked M1 8GB MacBook Airs that are bricked because the SSD used up it's write cycles [VIDEO] — hermanzegerman, 2026-03
I'm pretty sure part of the reason of integrating everything on the board has some nefarious reasons, at least on Laptop's. Louis Rossman talked about a design flaw in Apple Macbooks where if the SSD fails, in my cases, your system will fail to power up because the mainboard is designed to fail when the SSD fails.(If I am interpreting that correctly)[0]. Remember this flaw is in the Macbooks wher… — trinsic2, 2025-12
I hope one day they can fix the engineering problems so I can buy a machine and keep it for more than two years without fear of some cheap components exploding. A purchased computer should work for a decade at least. If this sounds over the top, look at what the repair shop guys are saying... Edit: Thanks for the downvotes, its not popular but an unfortunate reality. These issues are related to 2… — replete, 2024-08
There absolutely are issues, whether you accept it or not, and it is nothing to do with 'not trusting TPM'. Apple SSDs engineered in the worst way possible: [VIDEO] Exploding USB-C MacBook Ports Explained: [LINK] — replete, 2024-08

Related videos