Why China Is so Good at Building Railways

Channel:Wendover Productions · Length:12:12 · Published:2018-11-13 · Views:8656367

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Wendover Productions explainer on how China built the world's largest high-speed rail network so quickly and why its rail strategy differs from America's. It covers politics, social benefits and the economics of unprofitable lines.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to short video when threads compare Chinese and US rail and infrastructure.

Please, I urge you to watch this. — HN, 2019

Geopolitics & foreign policy · Transit, cities & urban planning · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

This video was made possible by Squarespace. Build your beautiful website for 10% off at squarespace.com/Wendover. Imagine a train that took you from Washington, DC to Dallas, Texas in nine hours… or Paris, France to Athens, Greece in nine hours… or Adelaide, South Australia to Perth, Western Australia in nine hours. These train trips actually take 44 hours, 44 hours, and 41 hours respectively so the idea of making any of these trips by train in nine hours seems almost absurd. In China, though, that’s reality. In September, 2018 the country opened up a brand new high speed rail route with d irect trains from Hong Kong to Beijing. This is about the same distance as DC to Dallas, Paris to Athens, or Adelaide to Perth and yet these trains make the trip in only 8 hours and 56 minutes. What makes this even more impressive is that ten years ago, in 2008, at the time of the Beijing Olympics, China’s high-speed rail network consisted of this. We’ll have to zoom in because the extent of the network was one 19 mile-long Maglev train from Shanghai Airport to the outskirts of Shanghai and a traditional high-speed rail line from Beijing to the coastal city of Tianjin. Today, ten years later, that network has expanded into this.

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] Please, I urge you to watch this. It explains thoroughly why the situation for railroads is very different between China and America. tl;dw: America is more spread out, has better airline control, and less of a political incentive to expand public transport, than China. — WilliamEdward, 2019-10
This Wendover Productions video "Why China Is so Good at Building Railways" [VIDEO] also explains a lot about how things have changed recently to make this migration even more possible in China. They've built so much high speed rail in the last decade that they now have more than the rest of the world, combined. Hong Kong to Beijing is under 9 hours, while comparable distances in other parts of t… — s1mon, 2019-02
Wendover had a good video about China's rail network a while ago. [1] Major points are: 1. China is willing to build loves that aren't self sustainable - whereas the USA isn't (and the US doesn't factor in the social benefits) 2. China's airspace is mostly military - leading to only small flight corridors and therefore significant delays for flights - making trains more reliable 3. China is willi… — lunchbreak, 2018-12
Here's a good video summarizing what China has done with high speed rail in a little over a decade: [VIDEO] — Fricken, 2018-12
Eat our lunch? They already had dinner and dessert. Public urban transit in tier 1&2 cities is world class. In 2014, Shanghai began line 17 construction and opened the line with 13 stations by 2017. [LINK] In 2014, Washington DC started the 6 station silver line extension(phase 2) to connect to the airport at Dulles and it's still not done. [LINK] As for passenger trains, the US is not even a con… — neither_color, 2021-02

Related videos