TEDxCopenhagen - Mikael Colville-Andersen - Why We Shouldn't Bike with a Helmet

Channel:TEDx Talks · Length:16:34 · Published:2010-12-16 · Views:421070

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Copenhagen's bicycle ambassador Mikael Colville-Andersen argues in a TEDx talk that bicycle helmets threaten bicycle culture. He says they distract from road design and make cycling look dangerous.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in helmet-law debates as a watchable argument that helmet mandates may cost lives by discouraging cycling.

If you would rather watch than read, there's this — HN, 2016

Law, policing & justice · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

Transcriber: Diana Khakimova Reviewer: Capa Girl Thanks for calling me a young man! It's really cool to be here. Being hanging out with TED -- The good life. Those three words probably mean a whole lot of different things to a whole lot of different people. I have my own personal factors for what the good life means to me and my family. One of those things is bicycles or rather people on bicycles. A symphony of human powered movement across the cityscape. It's a large part of what I do. Promoting urban cycling in cities around the world. This is the age of lists, of measuring, of ratings, and indexes. And it's interesting to see how we try to determine, where the good life is being lived. Not long ago, It was done with simple lists of world's richest countries, world's poorest contries, richest cities, poorest cities. Money was the key factor in determining quality of life. Now, things are much different as we all know. Now we have stuff like the world's happiest nation survey, which continues to baffle and confuse the Danish people, year after year by placing them number one. I still don't get it. A lifestyle magazine Monocle has developed a world's most liveable cities index a few years ago, using an interesting combination

On Hacker News

If this is a new topic to you (I don't mean, you , SturgeonsLaw, as you are clearly familiar with it :) -- I mean the reader), you would do well to consider both sides. I personally find the arguments that bike helmets cause more harm than good persuasive, and a good and thorough introduction may be found here: [LINK] If you would rather watch than read, there's this: [VIDEO] — Dove, 2016-09
[VIDEO] Anyone just blindly downvoting snovv_crash should check out the video above and any number of other resources, such as this one: [LINK] There are strong feelings on both sides, but many cyclists feel helmets are a distraction from the real issues which make cyclists unsafe: poor road design and unsafe driving. Cycling itself is (counter-intuitively) a very safe activity which looks danger… — m0nty, 2016-08
reminds me of the bicycle helmet stuff. There was a ted talk that said bicycle helmet laws would kill more people than save. The reasoning was preventing people from riding would also prevent increased fitness, and more lives were lost from that than saved from accidents. EDIT: I think this one: [VIDEO] — m463, 2024-05
reminds me of the ted talk where the speaker said that helmet laws might be costing lives. The idea was that more people would be saved by the opportunity to exercise than were saved by the helmets. I think this one? [VIDEO] — m463, 2024-01
There are studies and talks that would suggest the opposite is true. For example:- For example: [LINK] TED talk discussing the issues: [VIDEO] Common sense would dictate that the helmet is safer, but we could argue the science leaves a lot to be desired. — ownagefool, 2016-09

Related videos