Equipment Review: Best Carbon-Steel Skillets (Can This One Pan Do It All?) & Our Testing Winner

Channel:America's Test Kitchen · Length:5:51 · Published:2015-08-10 · Views:1962533

Watch on YouTube

Summary

America's Test Kitchen tests eight carbon-steel skillets to find the best one, asking whether a single pan can replace stainless, cast iron and nonstick. It names a winner and covers how the pans perform.

Why HN recommends it

HN people link it as a solid explainer and review of carbon steel pans, and for seasoning guidance.

This is a solid explainer on carbon steel pans — HN, 2023

Cooking & food

Subtitles (excerpt)

even if you've never heard of a carbon steel Skillet you've almost certainly eaten food made in one restaurant chefs use carbon steel for everything from searing steak to sautéing onions to cooking eggs French omelette and crep pans are made of carbon steel and so are Chinese walks in European home kitchens these pans are hugely popular but somehow they've never really caught on with home Cooks in the United States but these pans have a reputation for being as great at Browning as they are for keeping delicate foods from sticking so we knew it was time to check them out we bought eight carbon steel Skillets all as close as possible to 12 in which is our preferred size for a primary Skillet carbon steel pans are surprisingly inexpensive most of these cost just $40 to $80 but out of curiosity we also included a $230 handforged pan made in Seattle now we tried our carbon steel pans with a wide variety of recipes because they're supposed to be able to do it all we fried eggs we made cheese omelets we pans seared steak we even made the traditional French upside down apple dessert called tart tatan this dessert begins on the stove with caramelizing apples and then moves to the oven to bake up the crust then you have to

On Hacker News

Carbon steel is much better than cast iron! It takes some time to build up a nonstick coating (seasoning), but once you do fried eggs will glide around like they’re on ice. I have a Mauviel that I love, but the Matfer Bourgeat is better for eggs because it doesn’t have the steel rivets on the inside of the pan. Both are made in France and cost like $70. This is a solid explainer on carbon steel p… — jointpdf, 2023-04
I'm a simple man, I see a post linking to a J. Kenji Lopez-Alt article, I upvote. Another good method is outlined in this America's Test Kitchen video [VIDEO] If you have a friend who runs a Chinese restaurant, you could always try this, too [LINK] I do this regularly and always clean my pan with soap after use. — iamacyborg, 2021-01
I've tried the flaxseed method, and while the seasoning looked good, it was very fragile. The best method I've found over more than a decade of cooking on cast iron and carbon steel is this one, recommended by Matfer-Bourgeat (who make the best pans IMO) and America's Test Kitchen (at 2:00): [VIDEO] — KozmoNau7, 2019-09
America's Test Kitchen had a nice roundup review of these the other day: [VIDEO] They also have some tips for seasoning them. — maskull, 2015-08

Related videos