My Framework Investment Should NOT Have Worked Out

Channel:Linus Tech Tips · Length:17:36 · Published:2025-02-25 · Views:2381875

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Linus Tech Tips covers Framework's newly announced devices, including its first desktop, with comments from Framework's CEO about the company's design decisions.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a source for the Framework CEO's explanation of why the desktop's memory could not be socketed or modular.

This sort-of-interview of Nirav Patel (ceo of framework) explains in a bit more detail — HN, 2025

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Consumer devices & gadgets

Subtitles (excerpt)

I might have invested in framework but I only find out all the cool stuff that they're up to like a couple days before you guys the good news is this time around I am absolutely jazzed against an army of Industry Giants I'm seemingly Against All Odds they not only continue to survive but in front of me is their biggest launch announcement yet I'm talking seventh gen framework 13 their fastest 13-in laptop yet an allnew 12-in convertible laptop with finally a touchcreen finally and wait a desktop did we really need framework to develop modular repairable desktops oh wait hold on a second this is new modular swappable front IO and look at this you can even swap these tiles this one has a segue to our sponsor ug green are you getting the storage warning on your phone again well a ug green NZ could be the solution with up to 64 tabt of storage it can store up to 22 million selfies and to keep them secure it comes with a built-in security manager to protect your data so check out the ugreen nas sync dxp 2800 at the link in the video description normally for a multi-product video we go from most exciting to less exciting and then save a pretty good one for the the end but I'm equally stoked for

On Hacker News

I agree, but here's a quote from the CEO explaining (to some degree) the choice: “So we did actually ask AMD about this the first time they told us about Strix Halo. It was literally our first question: ‘How do we get modular memory? We are Framework after all.’ And they didn’t say no actually, they did assign one of their technical architects to really really go deep on this—they ran simulations… — daemonologist, 2025-09
According to the Framework CEO on the Linus Tech Tips video about this thing [1], they tried and AMD assigned an engineer on getting modular memory to work and decided it's not possible. Unless there's another company out there shipping this CPU with replaceable memory, I'll believe them. Even with LPCAMM, physics just doesn't work out. Of course, there are plenty of slower desktops you can buy w… — jeroenhd, 2025-08
As stated previously, the sockets reduce signal integrity, which doesn't necessarily make them "bad," but is why Framework wasn't able to used socketed ram to maximize the potential of this CPU. This sort-of-interview of Nirav Patel (ceo of framework) explains in a bit more detail: [VIDEO] Basically, they need to use LPDDR5X memory, which isn't available in socketed form, because of signal integr… — komali2, 2025-08
[VIDEO] The ceo kind of explains why in this video. In essence it seems to be a limitation of the chip from AMD — rdedev, 2025-02
The two CPU models are i3-1215U and i5-1334U [1] which are 15 W parts with 2 P cores. They should be OK. [1] [VIDEO] — phonon, 2025-02

Related videos