Smarter than a Smart TV! (Raspberry Pi Inside)

Channel:Jeff Geerling · Length:9:10 · Published:2022-06-08 · Views:2413477

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jeff Geerling looks at a Sharp NEC commercial display with a slot for a Raspberry Pi Compute Module. It is a large screen without built-in smart TV features or tracking.

Why HN recommends it

Brought up in smart TV complaint threads as a real-world 'dumb display' alternative.

Jeff Geerling talks about how great a TV his non-TV is. — HN, 2023

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Embedded systems & DIY electronics · Consumer devices & gadgets

Subtitles (excerpt)

This is not a TV. Hey! That's my line! Anyways... It's actually a display, powered by a Raspberry Pi. Usually, when someone says "Raspberry Pi display," you probably think about something like this. It's a 5 inch touchscreen for the Pi. But this? This is the NEC Multisync MA551, but it's not a TV. It's a display. And it's a lot smarter than any of the terrible 'smart TVs' you'll find at the store. Why? Because it's running Linux! Heck, there's a Pi in here, so I could run Kodi or RetroPie right on the display for the ultimate living room TV. Just...you know, without the "TV" part. The funny thing is, even though this isn't considered a TV, it's probably the best TV I've ever used. And that's because NEC makes this display for the commercial market. Oh, I'm sorry, "Sharp NEC Display Solutions of America". I'll just call them "Sharp NEC" for the rest of this video. Instead of installing spyware or tons of buggy apps on their TV, they build these displays to run all day, every day, and they also make versions for outdoor use. Then even include cool features like automatic failover to different inputs if one fails, power schedules, and complete remote control either over the network, through the Pi, or even this built-in RS-232 serial port.

On Hacker News

A recent Jeff Geerling video dug into this subject. [0]. Sharp NEC [1] makes and sells TVs without any "smart" junk (they're mainly aimed at being 24/7 monitors/displays in businesses). They're significantly more expensive than consumer TVs, but part of that is likely to accommodate 24/7 usage. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — modriano, 2023-03
Just get a "display". See [VIDEO] where Jeff Geerling talks about how great a TV his non-TV is. He has an NEC UHD Professional Display M551. He gets to control the software on the embedded Raspberry Pi. It's about $1700 but I think it's worth it. Product link [LINK] — ararar, 2023-01
It would be so cool if it supported something like an insertable Raspberry Pi like these NEC displays did, but with standard consumer TV display characteristics (4k, > 60hz, etc) [VIDEO] — gclawes, 2023-04
The fact that it actually comes with a Raspberry Pi is incredibly cool to me. Oh, and of course there's a review of it from Jeff Geerling: [VIDEO] Actually, this thing has some pretty decent specs... my initial reaction was that it was overpriced, but now I'm thinking this is a decent deal for what you get. — antongribok, 2022-09
This comes up over and over again. There is a brand that sells through Wal Mart in the US (Sceptre) which tends to not have smart features. They are not high end sets. You can also get 'commercial' sets intended for signage that are apparently OK too. Jeff Geerling did a video on an interesting one from Sharp/NEC that takes a smart module, which can be a raspberry pi, here: [VIDEO] . There are so… — saxonww, 2022-08

Related videos