Assholes are Ruining Your Project. Donnie Berkholz (RedMonk).

Channel:Tom Raftery · Length:18:03 · Published:2012-02-20 · Views:5660

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Donnie Berkholz of RedMonk gives a Monki Gras talk arguing that abusive, toxic contributors damage open source projects. He makes the case for removing them from communities.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as the go-to evidence that rudeness drives contributors away and that toxic people must be removed from projects.

Assholes will ruin your project[1], you need to get rid of them — HN, 2014

Software practice, open source & careers · Management, leadership & organizations

Subtitles (excerpt)

[ __ ] May ruin your project and Donnie's going to tell you uh maybe what to do about it Donnie [Music] burhs thanks thanks for the uh overly kind introduction I'll I'll do my best to uh keep things interesting so um this project or I guess the story is all about uh the last eight or nine years I spent contributing to a Linux distribution called gentu and started out sort of in the trenches doing just my single developer thing and over time gradually ended up um in sort of a position of leadership and in open source you know that doesn't mean you get to tell people what to do it means you get to ask them what to do more often um and so over time um things were going great but then uh we ran into some tough times and um I'm going to show you some quantitation that I've tried to do on one of the hardest things to quantify which is people communities rather than code it's easy to quantify code we saw some of that with the cloud Foundry talk yesterday you can look a PL requests you can uh do all kinds of metrics on lines of code number of commits and so on but how do you quantify a community um and here's my alternate title I thought it fit um because that's what they do right and I guess here would

On Hacker News

Good call. A good video related to this: "Assholes Are Ruining Your Project. Donnie Berkholz (RedMonk)" [VIDEO] — Modified3019, 2023-09
The glibc team are great people to work with; I managed to get a patch into this release which had been point blank refused by Ulrich Drepper when he was maintainer, and they were incredibly helpful and the process was really easy. So get your fixes in - glibc is becoming much more standards compliant. Assholes will ruin your project[1], you need to get rid of them, whether it is open source or n… — justincormack, 2014-02
> I've noticed that claims like this are never backed by any evidence of this improvement, or evidence of people who actually have been chased away by rudeness. I am one of them. I've seen other people claim the same. I did not keep a list, nor did I keep a list of all of his posts that I found egregious, and I don't really feel like spending a lot of time crawling through all posts to find them,… — Beltalowda, 2023-01
Even though bad faith criticism and complaints can be useful, I find there is a still an insurmountable problem sometimes: it can be too time- and energy-consuming to handle the sheer quantity and/or intensity. Sometimes, especially at "political moments" (like elections in a project I was involved in recently - and I wasn't even a candidate), it can feel like being overwhelmed by a tidal wave. I… — jlokier, 2019-04
Exactly . You have to pick: either the jerks, or the people who the jerks drive away. And that doesn't take into account the people who aren't quite driven away but find work that much more unpleasant as a result. If you encounter many skilled jerks, consider why that might be, and why in the same environment you don't also encounter skilled people who are fun to work with. In such an environment… — JoshTriplett, 2017-02

Related videos