"You Have the Right to Remain Innocent" (James Duane)

Channel:The Cato Institute · Length:34:47 · Published:2016-09-30 · Views:893580

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Law professor James Duane explains why you should not talk to the police even if you are innocent, drawing on case histories of wrongful convictions. It is a short version of the argument in his book on the right to remain silent.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters send it to anyone who thinks innocent people have nothing to fear from answering police questions.

this is a very important video for everyone to watch — HN, 2021

Law, policing & justice

Subtitles (excerpt)

here's the book that he mentioned a moment ago you have the right to remain innocent as it says up there it's also available in audio version if you'd like to have the thrill of hearing me read the book to you and to your children as getting ready for bed a couple of brief before I talk about the book let me just make a couple of quick brief introductory comments about myself for the benefit of those of you who are thinking to yourself who is this guy why should I listen to him why should I care about his opinion that's a fair question uh I'm nobody of any particular statute but I know some important people there's just as answered in Scalia and me a picture of us taken together in his Chambers actually just a few months before his tragic and untimely demise uh just before we went out to lunch together he was I'm a great admirer of that man he was a legal giant uh and here for those of you on the left is my friend Loretta Lynch the US attorney general and me posing together at our recent uh College reunion we were college and law school classmates and I'm also a great fan of hers as well I I'm not sure but I think I may be the only American who actually hug Loretta and Nino both in the past year but I need to give you a

On Hacker News

Yup, this is a very important video for everyone to watch, but especially anyone moving to America who doesn't understand the differences to policing in this country vs others. If you have watched this video, you might want to review this highly anticipated follow up several years later: [VIDEO] — dotBen, 2021-12
If anyone reads the parent here and doesn't agree then watch "You Have the Right to Remain Innocent" by James Duane. [VIDEO] — keanzu, 2020-03
To my other comment, let me add that this follow up video by Duane specifically addresses your scenario: the concerned parents of a missing girl unwisely spoke to the cops, without knowing they were suspects in the case (because the cops regularly suspect this, "9 out of 10 times, the caller is the one who committed the crime" as one cop put it). In this case, the cops suspected the father. After… — the_af, 2023-01
Yes, that is a presentation worth watching [0] and a follow-up [1]. Even as someone who is pro law enforcement, I have to keep in mind that their job does not always align with protecting you. In other words, if they pull you over for speeding, the relationship isn't the same as the case where you might be asking a cop for directions or if you are engaging with them because you were a victim of a… — robomartin, 2021-08
A lot of discussion in this thread about traffic stops. James Duane (the law professor from the video in the blog) himself makes a qualifier about traffic stops: [VIDEO] — iwhalen, 2026-06

Related videos