Animated Voting Methods

Channel:Unify The Vote · Length:6:18 · Published:2017-06-16 · Views:15788

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An animated simulation comparing single-winner voting methods such as plurality, instant runoff and STAR. Colored regions show which candidate wins as a randomized electorate shifts across a two-dimensional political space, building on Ka-Ping Yee's earlier diagrams.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it in voting-reform threads as a visual argument that cardinal systems (STAR, approval) beat plurality and ranked-choice voting.

I always recommend this pair of videos when discussing STAR voting vs other alternative systems. — HN, 2019

Data visualization & information design · Probability & game theory · US politics & elections

Subtitles (excerpt)

This video uses the magic of computer graphics to show visually how well various voting methods actually work in terms of electing someone who represents the electorate. It turns out our current system, and bunch of other proposed systems, don't actually do very well in terms of accurately representing the will of the voters. So let's just imagine we have two candidates, your typical red and blue. They're represented by colored circles in the virtual two-dimensional political spectrum. Now we'll just add a single voter, who gets to determine the winner of the election. In this simulation the voter just picks whichever candidate is closest. As the voter moves politically closer to the other candidate, that candidate becomes the winner. Now we're going to paint the whole background with whichever candidate would win when the voter is at each point in the political spectrum. We can add candidates: now there are three or four or five, and the winner of the election at each point is just whichever candidate is closest to that single voter that's picking the winner. As we animate the candidates through the political spectrum, this makes for pretty pictures but it's not particularly useful.

On Hacker News

I always recommend this pair of videos when discussing STAR voting vs other alternative systems. The first video is an easy-to-follow explanation of how spoiler effects can happen in both plurality voting and IRV [1]. In the second [2], the guy who created Star voting applies Ka-Ping Yee's methods to Star voting and animates it side-by-side with alternative systems to show its performance. [1] [L… — user234683, 2019-10
The first link there does actually compare against ranked choice. It is just called IRV. There's a larger comparison that includes more types of ranked choice (also called "ordinal") here[0]. Though I particularly like this animation[1]. I'll also add that there is a lot of nuance to voting and VSE isn't everything. There's a lot of factors to consider including: how do strategies work? Is it sca… — godelski, 2021-11
Ranked Choice Voting is not really a good idea. It has very strange unintuitive behavior. Doing Score based voting is just much better and arguably simpler and less work. I specially like the Star-Voting, where they do a runoff at the end to cover some extra cases. They also have a few variants for multi-winner and representational voting. Its also much more familiar for people from real live, li… — nickik, 2021-06
Simple answer: The math says so [VIDEO] Longer answer: cardinal systems (the generalized form that approval is part of) is able to capture more information about voter preference. It is easiest to see this with something like range voting. You may be familiar with a question like "Do you agree or disagree with x statement?: strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree, strongly agree." That is ran… — godelski, 2020-10
RP has a resolve time of O(n4) so I'm not sure that's a method you want to argue for under a thread where (an even lower) complexity led to a critical mistake. It would be naive to maximize VSE over all other criteria. I cannot stress enough that there are no optimal systems and that we cannot look at criteria independently. > I don't understand how you don't understand the argument. Because pure… — godelski, 2022-12

Related videos